Voltage Regulators VS DC-DC converters

How do I choose a voltage regulator?

There are three major types of voltage regulators that you will encounter in this program:

  • Linear voltage regulator - burns off extra power in the form of heat
    • Advantage: High current capacity
    • Advantage: Low cost
    • Disadvantage: Low precision
    • Disadvantage: High dropout voltage (the voltage difference between the input and output)
  • Low dropout voltage regulator - burns off extra power in the form of heat, but continues to regulate even when the input voltage is near the output voltage
    • Advantage: Excellent for battery-powered applications
    • Advantage: Higher precision
    • Disadvantage: Lower current capacity
    • Disadvantage: Higher cost
  • Switching voltage regulator - generates as much power as is needed by the circuit, up to the maximum allowed by the regulator. Similar to Switching Power Supplies above
    • Advantage: Highly energy efficient
    • Disadvantage: High cost
    • Disadvantage: External components (some difficult to find) may be necessary
    • Disadvantage: Printed circuit board layout can be difficult
  • DC-DC Converter - An Isolated power converter. (No electrical connection between input and output)
    • Advantage: Can be used on sensitive equipment that need an isolated power supply
    • Disadvantage: Requires more testing to guarantee isolation.
    • Disadvantage: External components (some difficult to find) may be necessary
    • Disadvantage: Noise due to PWM signal switching

A highly detailed guide to linear and switching regulators is available here: http://www.ti.com/lit/an/snva558/snva558.pdf

When should I use a DC-DC Converter?

A DC-DC converter should be used when the following is needed:

  • Higher efficiency (95% when compared to linear voltage regulator of 65%)
  • Power that can be stepped up or stepped down
  • A moderate - high max voltage output.